Difference between revisions of "1° Clinical case: Hemimasticatory spasm"

no edit summary
Line 3: Line 3:


[[File:Spasmo emimasticatorio.jpg|left|300x300px]]
[[File:Spasmo emimasticatorio.jpg|left|300x300px]]
In the previous chapters we have considered the diagnostic complexity in medicine taking into account especially some parameters such as the hidden variables that only the evolution of basic knowledge over time will allow us to identify and the difficulties in decoding the encrypted signal that the Central Nervous System sends to the external in the form of verbal language.  
This chapter, part of a series dedicated to dissecting the complexities of medical diagnostics, particularly focuses on the challenging diagnosis and subsequent treatment of "Hemimasticatory Spasm" in the patient Mary Poppins. After enduring ten years of uncertainty and a barrage of tests crossing multiple medical disciplines, including dentistry and neurology, her case exemplifies the intricate interplay between various bodily systems and the need for a refined diagnostic approach that embraces mathematical models and advanced neurophysiological understanding.


Last but not least, the limitations imposed by a deterministic mindset that reduces knowledge in specialist contexts by limiting its diagnostic capacity. An alternative mindset to deterministics that primarily considers a logic of fuzzy language and the important contribution of quantum probability would allow us to expand the scientific-clinical horizons and delve into a mesoscopic reality.
The narrative underscores the limitations of conventional diagnostic frameworks, often hindered by deterministic thinking that fails to capture the nuanced reality of human physiology. The chapter advocates for the integration of quantum probability and fuzzy logic into medical diagnostics, proposing a shift towards a more probabilistic and nuanced interpretation of patient symptoms and test results. This approach is not only more reflective of the complex nature of many medical conditions but also paves the way for more accurate and individualized patient care.


In this chapter, therefore, we will deal with the diagnosis of our Mary Poppins following the scientific-clinical process, evaluating the difficulties of implementation and the added value of the encrypted code identified in the hepaptic transmission.{{ArtBy|
Mary Poppins' diagnosis was complicated by overlapping symptoms and the lack of a clear demarcation between dental and neurological issues. Traditional diagnostic methods fell short, leading to a prolonged period of suffering due to the inability to correctly interpret her condition. The introduction of the "ephaptic transmission" concept — a nuanced understanding of nerve communication affected by her condition — highlights the importance of sophisticated diagnostic tools and models that can differentiate between similar symptoms caused by different underlying conditions.
 
The chapter delves into the philosophical and epistemological foundations that underpin current medical practices. It critiques the reliance on outdated paradigms that compartmentalize medical conditions into narrowly defined categories, often ignoring the broader systemic nature of many disorders. By invoking Thomas Kuhn's theory of scientific revolutions, the text challenges the medical community to reconsider and possibly overthrow existing models that are inadequate for addressing the complexities of human health.
 
Moreover, the chapter discusses the role of "fuzzy logic" in diagnostics, which allows for a range of possibilities rather than binary outcomes, thus reflecting the reality of many medical conditions that do not fit neatly into 'sick' or 'healthy' categories. This is particularly relevant in the case of neurological disorders, where symptoms can be transient or vary in intensity, making them difficult to classify with traditional binary diagnostic tools.
 
The story of Mary Poppins is used to illustrate these points vividly. Her journey through the medical system, marked by misdiagnoses and partial treatments, exemplifies the dire consequences of inadequate diagnostic models. Her eventual correct diagnosis, facilitated by a better understanding of the "ephaptic transmission" within her trigeminal system, underscores the potential for improved patient outcomes when innovative and interdisciplinary approaches are employed.
 
In conclusion, this chapter calls for a paradigm shift in medical diagnostics. It argues for the abandonment of purely mechanical interpretations of diseases like malocclusions, advocating instead for a holistic, system-oriented view that incorporates the latest advancements in neurophysiology and quantum mechanics. Such a shift not only promises better diagnostic accuracy but also aligns more closely with the complex reality of human biology, potentially revolutionizing the way health care professionals understand and treat their patients.
 
The chapter closes by reinforcing the need for continuous education and openness to new ideas among medical professionals, suggesting that the future of effective medical treatment relies heavily on our ability to integrate diverse scientific insights and emerging technologies into everyday clinical practice.<blockquote>
== Keywords ==
'''Hemimasticatory Spasm''': A keyword focusing on the specific medical condition discussed in the chapter, which involves involuntary muscle contractions affecting the masticatory muscles, primarily due to neurological issues.
 
'''Quantum Mechanics in Medicine''': A keyword that highlights the innovative approach of applying quantum mechanics principles to medical diagnostics, suggesting a shift from classical deterministic models to probabilistic models in understanding and diagnosing medical conditions.
 
'''Ephaptic Transmission''': This keyword relates to the advanced neurophysiological concept discussed as central to diagnosing Mary Poppins' condition, involving abnormal nerve communication that plays a critical role in neuromuscular disorders.
 
'''Neurological Diagnosis''': A broad keyword that encompasses the use of advanced neurological testing and analysis to diagnose conditions that manifest through complex symptoms, as exemplified by the patient's long journey toward an accurate diagnosis.
 
'''Fuzzy Logic in Diagnostics''': A keyword that introduces the concept of fuzzy logic in medical diagnostics, promoting an understanding that embraces ambiguity and a spectrum of possibilities rather than binary outcomes.
 
'''Interdisciplinary Medical Approach''': Emphasizes the necessity of integrating knowledge from various medical fields (such as dentistry, neurology, and dermatology) to achieve accurate diagnoses and effective treatments, as demonstrated in the complex case study.
 
'''Systemic Medical Disorders''': A keyword focusing on disorders that involve multiple body systems, underlining the need for comprehensive diagnostic approaches that go beyond looking at isolated symptoms.
 
'''Medical Diagnostic Paradigms''': Discusses the shift required in medical thinking and diagnostic models, from traditional methods to more integrated, systemic approaches that consider the interplay between different bodily systems.
 
'''Dental and Neurological Overlap''': Highlights the diagnostic challenges and complexities when dental symptoms overlap with neurological disorders, necessitating a nuanced understanding and collaborative medical efforts.
 
'''Patient-Centric Diagnostics''': A keyword emphasizing the shift towards diagnostics that focus more on individual patient symptoms and histories, aligning with personalized medicine approaches for better health outcomes.</blockquote>
 
{{ArtBy|
| autore = Gianni Frisardi
| autore = Gianni Frisardi
| autore2 = Giorgio Cruccu
| autore2 = Giorgio Cruccu
Line 16: Line 48:
| }}
| }}


=== Introduction ===
===Introduction===
From what has been exposed in the previous chapters from the 'Introduction' to the '[[Logic of medic language]]' chapters, beyond the complexity of the arguments and the vagueness of the verbal language, we found ourselves faced with a dilemma that of the context in which the patient is referred and in these cases for our poor Mary Poppins it seems to dominate the dental context, given the positive assertions reported by the clinical and laboratory tests performed on the patient.
From what has been exposed in the previous chapters from the 'Introduction' to the '[[Logic of medic language]]' chapters, beyond the complexity of the arguments and the vagueness of the verbal language, we found ourselves faced with a dilemma that of the context in which the patient is referred and in these cases for our poor Mary Poppins it seems to dominate the dental context, given the positive assertions reported by the clinical and laboratory tests performed on the patient.


Line 30: Line 62:
*A set of {{:F:Im}} sentences, and a <math>n\geq1</math> number of other <math>(\gamma_1,\gamma_2,.....\gamma_n \ )</math> statements they are logically incompatible if, and only if, the union between them <math>\Im\cup\{\gamma_1,\gamma_2.....\gamma_n\}</math> it is inconsistent
*A set of {{:F:Im}} sentences, and a <math>n\geq1</math> number of other <math>(\gamma_1,\gamma_2,.....\gamma_n \ )</math> statements they are logically incompatible if, and only if, the union between them <math>\Im\cup\{\gamma_1,\gamma_2.....\gamma_n\}</math> it is inconsistent


==== Significance of contexts ====
====Significance of contexts====
Now, for the '''dental context''' we will have the following sentences and assertions to which we give a numerical value to facilitate the treatment and that is <math>\delta_n=[0|1]</math> where <math>\delta_n=0</math> indicates' normality' and <math>\delta_n=1</math> 'abnormality' and therefore positivity of the report:
Now, for the '''dental context''' we will have the following sentences and assertions to which we give a numerical value to facilitate the treatment and that is <math>\delta_n=[0|1]</math> where <math>\delta_n=0</math> indicates' normality' and <math>\delta_n=1</math> 'abnormality' and therefore positivity of the report:


Line 129: Line 161:
Once we have washed away the myriad of positively reported normative data, which generate conflicts between contexts, thanks to the coherence marker <math>\tau</math> we have a much clearer and more linear picture on which to deepen the analysis of the functionality of the Central Nervous System. Consequently we can concentrate on intercepting the tests necessary to decrypt the machine language code that the SNC sends out converted into verbal language.
Once we have washed away the myriad of positively reported normative data, which generate conflicts between contexts, thanks to the coherence marker <math>\tau</math> we have a much clearer and more linear picture on which to deepen the analysis of the functionality of the Central Nervous System. Consequently we can concentrate on intercepting the tests necessary to decrypt the machine language code that the SNC sends out converted into verbal language.


=== Ephaptic transmission ===
===Ephaptic transmission===
With a little effort and patience on the part of passionate readers who have followed the entire logical path, sometimes apparently off topic, we have reached a clinical picture in which the code to be decrypted is inherent in neuromotor damage. Consequently, the access keys to the code, the one that figuratively corresponds to the exact decryption algorithm, would correspond to the right choice of the neuromotor damage detector test.   
With a little effort and patience on the part of passionate readers who have followed the entire logical path, sometimes apparently off topic, we have reached a clinical picture in which the code to be decrypted is inherent in neuromotor damage. Consequently, the access keys to the code, the one that figuratively corresponds to the exact decryption algorithm, would correspond to the right choice of the neuromotor damage detector test.   


Line 172: Line 204:
  }}</ref>   
  }}</ref>   


====M-wave ====
====M-wave====
The right masseter nerve was electrically stimulated in the infratemporal fossa (see clinical procedure chapter: [[Encrypted code: Ephaptic transmission]]) with a technique similar to that described by Macaluso & De Laat (1995).<ref>Macaluso G, De Laat A. [https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8773249/ H-reflexes in masseter and temporalis muscle in man. Experimental] Brain Research. 1995;107:315–320. [PubMed] [Google Scholar] [Ref list]</ref> Square cathode pulses (0.1 ms) generated by an electrical stimulator (Neuropack X1, Nihon Kohden Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) were delivered through a Teflon-coated monopolar needle electrode (TECA 902-DMG25, 53534) with a tip non-isolated (diameter 0.36 mm; area 0.28 mm2) inserted 1.5 cm through the skin below the zygomatic arch and anterior to the temporomandibular joint in the infratemporal fossa with electrical shocks of 0.5 - 5 mA, and 0.1 ms. The anode was a surface non-polarizable Ag-AgCl disc electrode (OD 9.0 mm) positioned over the ipsilateral ear lobe. Electrical stimulation of the masseter nerve never produced pain, and the subjects only perceived muscle contraction. The correct position of the stimulation electrodes was monitored throughout the experimental session by checking online the size of the M wave in the masseter muscle. The signals were recorded by placing surface electrodes on the masseter and temporal muscles and filtered at 10-2000Hz and by concentric needle electrodes inserted into the anterior temporal muscle.   
The right masseter nerve was electrically stimulated in the infratemporal fossa (see clinical procedure chapter: [[Encrypted code: Ephaptic transmission]]) with a technique similar to that described by Macaluso & De Laat (1995).<ref>Macaluso G, De Laat A. [https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8773249/ H-reflexes in masseter and temporalis muscle in man. Experimental] Brain Research. 1995;107:315–320. [PubMed] [Google Scholar] [Ref list]</ref> Square cathode pulses (0.1 ms) generated by an electrical stimulator (Neuropack X1, Nihon Kohden Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) were delivered through a Teflon-coated monopolar needle electrode (TECA 902-DMG25, 53534) with a tip non-isolated (diameter 0.36 mm; area 0.28 mm2) inserted 1.5 cm through the skin below the zygomatic arch and anterior to the temporomandibular joint in the infratemporal fossa with electrical shocks of 0.5 - 5 mA, and 0.1 ms. The anode was a surface non-polarizable Ag-AgCl disc electrode (OD 9.0 mm) positioned over the ipsilateral ear lobe. Electrical stimulation of the masseter nerve never produced pain, and the subjects only perceived muscle contraction. The correct position of the stimulation electrodes was monitored throughout the experimental session by checking online the size of the M wave in the masseter muscle. The signals were recorded by placing surface electrodes on the masseter and temporal muscles and filtered at 10-2000Hz and by concentric needle electrodes inserted into the anterior temporal muscle.   


Line 186: Line 218:
Having highlighted, through the execution of the <math>M-wave</math> and <math>_bRoot-MEPs</math> test, a delay in the conduction speed of the trigeminal nerve fibers generates the suspicion that it is a focal demyelination. This indicates that the problem is to be referred to the nervous component rather than to the muscular one, therefore, our attention should focus on the type of focal demyelination, extent of damage and presumably localization of the damage. The differential diagnosis at this point focuses on the type and area of the demyelinating damage, for example, if it is a damage exclusively referred to the masseterine motor nerve or the motor nerve of the temporal muscle is also involved, important for treatment with botulinum endotoxin. To resolve this doubt it is necessary to evoke a heteronymous <math>H-wave</math> response from recording on the temporal muscle.
Having highlighted, through the execution of the <math>M-wave</math> and <math>_bRoot-MEPs</math> test, a delay in the conduction speed of the trigeminal nerve fibers generates the suspicion that it is a focal demyelination. This indicates that the problem is to be referred to the nervous component rather than to the muscular one, therefore, our attention should focus on the type of focal demyelination, extent of damage and presumably localization of the damage. The differential diagnosis at this point focuses on the type and area of the demyelinating damage, for example, if it is a damage exclusively referred to the masseterine motor nerve or the motor nerve of the temporal muscle is also involved, important for treatment with botulinum endotoxin. To resolve this doubt it is necessary to evoke a heteronymous <math>H-wave</math> response from recording on the temporal muscle.


====H-wave ====
====H-wave====
The arrangement is similar to that previously described with regard to the <math>M-wave</math> with the variant that the temporal muscle is recorded simultaneously with the stimulation of the masseterine nerve in the intratemporal fossa by a bipolar needle electrode. The stimulation must be gradually adapted in order to evoke both a <math>M-wave</math> from the masseter that a heteronymous <math>H-wave</math> from the temporal muscle.
The arrangement is similar to that previously described with regard to the <math>M-wave</math> with the variant that the temporal muscle is recorded simultaneously with the stimulation of the masseterine nerve in the intratemporal fossa by a bipolar needle electrode. The stimulation must be gradually adapted in order to evoke both a <math>M-wave</math> from the masseter that a heteronymous <math>H-wave</math> from the temporal muscle.


Line 194: Line 226:


As previously mentioned and in order not to burden the topic, the detailed description of the 'Hephaptic' phenomenon will be treated in the chapter '[[Encrypted code: Ephaptic transmission]]' in order to better understand the physiological responses of heteronymous <math>H-wave</math> by pathological ones.
As previously mentioned and in order not to burden the topic, the detailed description of the 'Hephaptic' phenomenon will be treated in the chapter '[[Encrypted code: Ephaptic transmission]]' in order to better understand the physiological responses of heteronymous <math>H-wave</math> by pathological ones.




[[File:Hephaptic edited.jpeg|center|thumb|600x600px|'''Figure 10:''' On the left side indicated with EMG the recording of the motor unit discharge on the right masseter at the time of the spasm is shown while on the right below indicated with M-wave we can see two motor potentials evoked by the electrical stimulation in infratemporal fossa recorded on the masseter. With H-wave it is possible to note the recording of the heteronomous H-wave on the temporal ipsilateral to the stimulation.]]
[[File:Hephaptic edited.jpeg|center|thumb|600x600px|'''Figure 10:''' On the left side indicated with EMG the recording of the motor unit discharge on the right masseter at the time of the spasm is shown while on the right below indicated with M-wave we can see two motor potentials evoked by the electrical stimulation in infratemporal fossa recorded on the masseter. With H-wave it is possible to note the recording of the heteronomous H-wave on the temporal ipsilateral to the stimulation.]]


=== Conclusions ===
=== Conclusions===


Following this step by step path we have demonstrated a peripheral motor nerve injury as originally proposed by Kaufman.<ref name="kauf">Kaufman MD. [https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7436363/ Masticatory spasm in facial hemiatrophy]. Ann Neurol 1980;7:585-7.</ref> Conduction studies have shown a slowing of conduction in the extracranial course of masticatory nerve fibers without a reduction in the amplitude of <math>M-wave</math> and obviously EMG signs of chronic denervation. The temporal muscle biopsy appeared histologically normal.
Following this step by step path we have demonstrated a peripheral motor nerve injury as originally proposed by Kaufman.<ref name="kauf">Kaufman MD. [https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7436363/ Masticatory spasm in facial hemiatrophy]. Ann Neurol 1980;7:585-7.</ref> Conduction studies have shown a slowing of conduction in the extracranial course of masticatory nerve fibers without a reduction in the amplitude of <math>M-wave</math> and obviously EMG signs of chronic denervation. The temporal muscle biopsy appeared histologically normal.
Editor, Editors, USER, admin, Bureaucrats, Check users, dev, editor, founder, Interface administrators, member, oversight, Suppressors, Administrators, translator
11,073

edits